摘要
13世纪拉丁阿维洛伊主义提出的“统一理智论”对基督教灵魂个体性、不朽性及救赎理论等核心教义构成严峻挑战。作为方济各会领袖、奥古斯丁传统的重要继承者与虔诚信仰的捍卫者,圣波纳文图拉对此理论展开了系统且激烈的驳斥。本文旨探讨波纳文图拉驳斥“统一理智论”的神哲学基础、内在逻辑及其带来的深远影响。
关键词: 波纳文图拉;统一理智论;拉丁阿维洛伊主义;灵魂不朽
Abstract
The "unitary intellectual theory" proposed by 13th-century Latin Averroism posed a severe challenge to core Christian doctrines such as the individuality of the soul, immortality, and salvation. As the leader of the Franciscan Order, a key inheritor of the Augustinian tradition, and a devoted defender of the faith, Saint Bonaventure launched a systematic and vehement refutation of this theory. This article explores the theological and philosophical foundations, internal logic , and the far-reaching impact of Bonaventure's refutation of the "unitary intellectual theory."
Key words: Bonaventura; Unitary intellectual theory; Latin Averroism; Immortality of the soul
参考文献 References
[1] Aquinas,Summa Contra Gentiles,Book Ⅱ,ed. J. Anderson,New York: Image Books,1956, P178-179.
[2] (古希腊)亚里士多德:《灵魂论及其他》[M],1995,第151-153页.
[3] R. Mclnerny , Aquinas against Averroists : on there being only one intellect, Indianna: Purdue University Press, 1993, P162.
[4] 徐弢:“阿奎那对统一理智论的批判及其神哲学意义”[J],选自《基督教思想评论》(第二辑)[M],上海:世纪出版集团、上海人民出版社,2005年,第41页.
[5] Etienne Gilson :The Philosophy of ST. Bonaventure, New Jersey:St. Anthony Guild Press Paterson, 1965, P309.
[6] 波纳文图拉著,溥林 黄路苹译《短论》[M],香港:道风书社,2008,序言14.
[7] Carl A. et al :God's Knowledge of the World: Medieval Theories of Divine Ideas from Bonaventure to Ockham,Washington,D.C.:TheCatholic University of America Press,2022, P272.
[8] Zachery Hayes et al :Saint Bonaventure's Disputed Questions on the Mystery of the Trinity: New york: The Franciscan Institute St. Bonaventure university,2000,P156.