期刊目次

加入编委

期刊订阅

添加您的邮件地址以接收即将发行期刊数据:

Open Access Article

Modern Social Science Research. 2025; 5: (11) ; 1-9 ; DOI: 10.12208/j.ssr.20250418.

The reaction of market participants to vies: a perspective of adaptive efficiency
资本市场参与者对可变利益实体的反应:以适应性效率为视角

作者: 郁光华 *

澳门科技大学 中国澳门

*通讯作者: 郁光华,单位:澳门科技大学 中国澳门;

发布时间: 2025-11-13 总浏览量: 77

摘要

本文研究在历史演变过程中,资本市场参与者,在中国资本市场发展早期市场细小、资金主要用于国企改革、监管苛严和充满不定性的情况下,是如何把美国会计并表监管规定用来实现境外间接发行上市的。事实表明无论是行为主体还是中国的监管机构对VIE境外间接发行上市的处理是符合适应性效率的。文章的第二个贡献是说明仅仅强调法律非正式主义只能够看到问题的局部,但事实上法律正式主义和非正式主义是相辅相成且相互影响的,二者结合才能够更好地剖析并完善资本市场的活动规则。文章的第三个贡献在于学术层面,只有更好地将研究的问题理论化,我们才能接近真理。

关键词: 适应性效率;法律正式主义;法律非正式主义;经济发展;理论化问题

Abstract

Through observing participants, when China has a thin stock market, capital was mainly devoted to reforming the SOEs, and regulation was strict and uncertain, in their adoption of American accounting rules on VIEs to serve the purpose of indirectly issuing and listing shares overseas, this article argues that responses of private parties and regulatory authorities are consistent with adaptive efficiency. The article’s second contribution is that we need to pay attention both to formal and informal institutions in explaining that formal institutions eventually adjusted to facilitating VIE indirect listing. The third contribution of this article is that better theorizing the issues under examination will help move closer to the truth.

Key words: Adaptive efficiency; Formal legal institutions; Informal legal institutions; Economic development; Theorizing issues

参考文献 References

[1] [美] Douglas C. North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance,Cambridge University Press, 1990, Chaps. 5 and 6; John McMillan & Christopher M. Woodruff, Private Order under Dysfunctional Public Order, 98 Michigan Law Review 2421 (2000).

[2] 有关合同的非正式实施,参见 [美] Lester Telser, A Theory of Self-enforcing Agreement, 53(1) Journal of Business 24 (1980); [美] Oliver Williamson, Credible Commitments: Using Hostage to Support Exchange, 73 American Economic Review 519 (1983); [美] Lisa Bernstein, Opting Out of the Legal System: Extralegal Contractual Relations in the Diamond Industry, 21 Journal of Legal Studies 115 (1992); [美] Greif, Avner, Contract Enforceability and Economic Institutions in Early Trade: The Maghribi Traders' Coalition, 83 (3) American Economic Review 525 (1993).

[3] 有关合同的正式实施,参见 [美] Christopher Clague et al., Contract-Intensive Money: Contract Enforcement, Property Rights, and Economic Performance, 4 Journal of Economic Growth 185, 188 (1999); [美] Rafael La Porta et al., Legal Determinants of External Finance, 52 Journal of Finance 1131, 1132 和1149 (1997); [美] Ross Levine et al.; Financial Intermediation and Growth: Causality and Causes, 46 Journal of Monetary Economics 31 (2000).

[4] 有关财产权正式和非正式实施的文献分析,参见[加] Michael Trebilcock and Paul-Erik Veel, Property Rights and Development: The Contingent Case for Formalization, 30 University of Pennsylvania Journal International Law 397 (2008).

[5] [加] Michael J. Trebilcock and Jing Leng, The Role of formal Contract Law and Enforcement in Economic Development, 92 Virginia Law Review 1517, 1573 (2006).

[6] [加] Michael Trebilcock and Paul-Erik Veel, Property Rights and Development: The Contingent Case for Formalization, 30 University of Pennsylvania Journal International Law 397 (2008).

[7] [中] Guanghua Yu, The Roles of Law and Politics in China’s Development,New York, Heidelberg and Singapore: Springer, 2014, Chaps 2 to 5; [中] Guanghua Yu, Adaptive Efficiency and Economic Development in China: The Definition and Enforcement of Property Rights, 11 Australian Journal of Asian Law 82 (2009).

[8] 参见[中] Jiahua Che and Yingyi Qian, Insecure Property Rights and Government Ownership of Firms, 113 The Quarterly Journal of Economics 467 (1998); [美] Donald Clarke, Economic Development and the Rights Hypothesis: The China Problem, 51 American Journal of Comparative Law 89, 109 (2003); [美] Allen, F, Qian Jun and Qian, Meijun, Law, Finance, and Economic Growth in China, 77 Journal of Financial Economics 57 (2005); [中] Xiaobo Zhang, Asymmetric Property Rights in China’s Economic Growth, 33 William Mitchell Law Review 567, 584 (2007); [美] Donald Clarke, Peter Murrell and Susan Whiting, The Role of Law in China’s Economic Development, in China’s Great Economic Transformation in Loren Brandt and Thomas G Rawski (eds), China’s Great Economic Transformation, Cambridge University Press, 2008; [美] Frank K. Upham, From Demsetz to Deng: Speculations on the Implications of Chinese Growth for Law and Development Theory, 41 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 551 (2009).

[9] [美] David Schindelheim, Variable Interest Entity Structures in the People’s Republic of China: Is Uncertainty for Foreign Investors Part of Economic Development Plan? 21 Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law 195, 207 (2012).

[10] [美] Markensie Larson, Alibaba’s VIE Structure and Erosion of BEPS Goals in China’s E-Commerce Industry, 33 Temple International and Comparative Law Journal 201, 209 (2019).

[11] [中] Li Guo, Chinese Style VIEs: Continuing to SNEAK under Smog? 47 Cornell International Law Journal 596, 573 (2014).

[12] [中] Li Guo, Chinese Style VIEs: Continuing to SNEAK under Smog? 47 Cornell International L Journal 596, 573 (2014).

[13] 刘燕:《企业境外间接上市的监管困境及其突破路径 – 以协议控制模式为分析对象》,载《法商研究》,2012年第5期,第14页.

[14] [美] Douglas C. North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance,Cambridge University Press, 1990, p. 80.

[15] [美] Douglas C. North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance,Cambridge University Press, 1990, p. 81.

[16] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 433 (2023); [中] Li Guo, Chinese Style VIEs: Continuing to SNEAK under Smog? 47 Cornell International Law Journal 596, 574 (2014); 和刘燕,《企业境外间接上市的监管困境及其突破路径 – 以协议控制模式为分析对象》,载《法商研究》,2012年第5期,第17页. 

[17] 唐应茂:《国际金融法-跨境融资和法律规则》(第二版),北京大学出版社,2020年版,第77-91页.

[18] A股历次IPO暂停时间及背景,https://weibo.com/ 1482739370/5065774196853132,2025年2月15日访问;重磅!刚刚证监会定调!保持IPO、再融资常态化,https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s?__biz=MzA4NjM2ODEyNw==&mid=2661257236&idx=1&sn=7096eb085dd3999faedbc16eabb06561&chksm=84a2fa04b3d57312e7a2dde0b2a8b7a5eb3fd1a5b56cfcaf1504436d181d3290ed50d3320868&scene=27, 2025年2月15日访问.

[19] 王啸和何秦:《当前企业发行上市体制下的若干问题探讨》,载《证券市场导报》,2010年12月号,第5页.

[20] 王啸和何秦:《当前企业发行上市体制下的若干问题探讨》,载《证券市场导报》,2010年12月号,第9页.

[21] 孙立,《对“无异议函时代”的分析报告》,载《金融法苑》,2003年第5期,第80页.

[22] 孙立,《对“无异议函时代”的分析报告》,载《金融法苑》,2003年第5期,第81页.

[23] 王仁荣,《VIE模式:山雨欲来风满楼》,载《上海金融》2011年10月,第23页.

[24] 励杨,《可变利益实体架构境外上市企业的全球最低税风险分析》,载《税务研究》2024年第8期,第102页;《中国上市企业在美国面临的监管与诉讼挑战》,https:// www.takungpao.com/special/239159/2024/0729/995651.html#:~:text= 2025年6月6日访问..

[25] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 450 (2023).

[26] [美] W. Tyler Perry, Development and Distrust: A Critique of the Orthodox Path to Economic Development,110 Northwestern University Law Review 477, 490 (2016).

[27] 刘燕,《企业境外间接上市的监管困境及其突破路径 – 以协议控制模式为分析对象》,载《法商研究》,2012年第5期,第18-19页.

[28] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 442 (2023).

[29] 刘燕,《企业境外间接上市的监管困境及其突破路径 – 以协议控制模式为分析对象》,载《法商研究》,2012年第5期,第20 页.

[30] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 438 (2023).

[31] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 434 (2023).

[32] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 439-40 (2023).

[33] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 446 (2023).

[34] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 468 (2023).

[35] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 453-54 (2023).

[36] 孔焕志、隋雪芹:《贸仲上海第一起VIE仲裁案》,载《商法》,2012年12月-2013年1月,第90页.

[37] [中] Shitong Qiao, Finance against Law: The Case of China, 64 Harvard International Law Journal 431, 451 (2023).

[38] 《证监会有关负责人答记者问》2021年12月24日,http://www.csrc.gov.cn/csrc/c100028/c1662240/content.shtml,2025年2月16日访问.

[39] 《证监会有关负责人答记者问》2021年12月24日,http://www.csrc.gov.cn/csrc/c100028/c1662240/content.shtml,2025年2月16日访问.

[40] [美] Justin J. Hopkins, Mark Lang & Donny Zhao, The Rise of VIEs in China: Balancing State Control and Access to Foreign Capital, Journal of Financial Reporting 105, 125 (2022).

[41] 《企业境外发行上市备案2024年度盘点》,载《国浩律师事务所》,https://www.grandall.com.cn/ghsd/info.aspx? itemid=30427,2025年2月17日访问;也请参见《中国证券期货统计年鉴》相关年份的IPO数据.

[42] [美] W. Tyler Perry, Development and Distrust: A Critique of the Orthodox Path to Economic Development, 110 Northwestern University Law Review 477, 482 (2016).

引用本文

郁光华, 资本市场参与者对可变利益实体的反应:以适应性效率为视角[J]. 现代社会科学研究, 2025; 5: (11) : 1-9.